ALTA says the attack on title insurance offers a false promise of savings

This blog never intends to discuss politics, so don’t interpret this post to take a political position. The intent is to inform real estate lawyers of news affecting our industry.

Just ahead of the State of the Union Address, President Biden announced plans to lower housing costs, calling on federal agencies to take all available actions to lower costs of consumers at the closing table and to help more Americans access homeownership. You can read the President’s Fact Sheet here.

Congress is asked to pass a mortgage relief credit that would provide middle-class first-time homebuyers with an annual tax credit of $5,000 a year for two years. Congress is also asked to provide a one-year tax credit of up to $10,000 to middle-class families who sell their starter homes, defined as homes below the area median home price in the county, to another owner-occupant. The intent of this proposal is to offset the loss of a lower interest rate when a homeowner sells. Congress is also asked to provide up to $25,000 in down payment assistance to first-generation homebuyers.

The President also proposes an expansion of the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit to build or preserve 1.2 million more affordable rental units. He also proposes a new $20 billion competitive grant fund to support communities to build more housing and lower rents and homebuying costs. Each Federal Home Loan Bank will be asked to double its annual contribution to the Affordable Housing Program. The intent will be to support the financing, acquisition, construction, and rehabilitation of affordable rental units and homes for sale.

Honestly, a lot of this seems like government-speak. We will have to wait to see the language of the actual proposals to form opinions, but lowering housing costs and providing more housing for low-income consumers is a great theory.

The one proposal that should concern practitioners is a pilot program to reduce closing costs by waiving the requirement for lender’s title insurance. At this point, the proposal only covers refinances, and the Fact Sheet indicates closing costs would be reduced by an average of $750. American Land Title Association (ALTA) issued a press release on March 7 stating that this proposal is a false promise of savings.

When I was in private practice, the cost of title insurance was less than the cost of an attorney’s opinion letter, and I believe lawyers would have to raise their charges to cover the additional liability. I’ve spoken many times and written many articles about the advantages of title insurance over title opinions, and I won’t repeat these arguments here. I am confident ALTA and title insurance companies will make those arguments plainly in opposition to this plan.